Sign Up  |  Help  |  Log In
Monday, February 13, 2012. New Comics in 2 days
 
 
 

The Transformers Ongoing #1

Rating:
Review by BW Media
Sunday November 22, 2009 06:47:48 pm
BW Media's Ratings:
Story:
Art:
Cover:
121
pulls
 
By: Mike Costa, Don Figueroa
(Potential spoilers in "What they got wrong" if you have avoided the previews.)

What they got right: Despite what I'm about to complain about, the story itself is well crafted. This is Costa's first trip into the TFU, having been chosen due to his work in the G.I. Joe comics for IDW. He makes the situation believable. I also enjoy much of Figueroa's art (as usual), and his mechanical designs are up to his usual talent.

What they got wrong: On the other hand, I don't understand why he's bringing in the movie style faces. It really doesn't work on Hot Rod, and many of the other mechs don't fair much better. However, my biggest gripe is a situation I'm pretty much tired of. While I don't expect the humans as a whole to start trusting all robots, even the Autobots, shouldn't the military realize that there are two factions? At the end of All Hail Megatron (before we got into the nightmare "Coda" issues), Sparkplug was sitting and talking to Kup, and Spike wasn't exactly using the "Shockwave gun" on the Autobots. He was warning them that the Autobots were going to have a tough time making friends. You know what I liked about Animated and one of the few things they DID get right in the second movie? Autobots and humans united against a common foe–the Decepticons. We never seem to get that in the comics, and I've pretty much had it with the Autobots being hunted like their Decepticons while the ‘Cons get away because they actually fight back or are able to get away in the confusion. This trend in the comics version has to stop!

Recommendation: It's OK thus far, but I'll have to check further issues to see where Costa goes with this storyline. I also wish Don would get back to the normal Transformer faces, or at least tell us who to blame for it.
 

Comments

sentinel of liberty (2 years ago)
 
I enjoyed it, pretty much thoroughly.
The story seems to be going somewhere new, but without tramping over the previous continuity. Pretty much what a first issue should do.
Optimus Prime's actions can be looked at favorably or unfavorably, dependant on your point of view, but I certainly trust the author to guide us to an acceptible end. I'm sure Prime has something up his sleeve, he almost always does. The only 'iteration' Optimus Prime that wasn't conflicted was the G1 Cartoon Optimus, and personally, I think a lack of conflict would make him cardboard (as if enough people don't feel that way WITH the conflict). Even still, his inner conflict has led him to take action, rather than simply wax poetic about it.
I'm not loving the faces with Don Figueroa's new look, but it's not a dealbreaker as long as the story is solid, which it is.
 
 
SirJon (2 years ago)
 
I won't say I disagree with you, only to add that I disliked nearly everything about this comic. Considering I even enjoyed the convoluted mess Dreamwave made of the Transformers, that's saying something. I haven't felt this disappointed in a TF comic since the mid-range Marvel run.
The story broke in two when it went from a present account to a flashback and couldn't sustain me after that. The continued wishy-washy-ness of Prime has become a detriment to a great and resolute character, one I miss quite a bit. Hot Rod was never a favorite of mine, but his Spotlight issues and the plots from within those books allowed him to grow on me. To have him continue to act as rashly as he has and still lose fellow Autobots should make him a pariah within the 'Bots, rather than one to lead, Rodimus or no. With no Matrix, can there even be a Rodimus Prime? Meh... getting ahead of myself. It just feels as if the whole of All Hail Megatron, the ongoing Spotlight plots and previous series have been swept under the rug to tell a story that is trying to emulate the films, which are not the Transformers I want to see.
I will agree with you on the artwork in that I dislike the attempt at making the TFs look more and more like the movie versions. I disagree with the more "mechanical" look in that I don't like it as much as you. I thought E.J. Su's work was really getting great at the tail end of All Hail Megatron and would have rather seen it continue to this book rather than get these somewhat Samurai armor styled Bots. Where's Andy Wildman when you need him?
Like you, I'll keep reading, but wow, what a disappointing first issue. I won't even mention the fact that the death (of a TF) seems like nothing more than a stunt for sales.
 
 

Would you like to comment?

Join comiXology for a free account, or Login if you are already a member.

Reviews by BW Media

  • Mega Man #10 by BW Media – 14 hours ago
  • Voltron #2 by BW Media – 2 days ago
  • Sonic the Hedgehog #233 by BW Media – 3 days ago
  • Jurassic Strike Force 5 #1 by BW Media – 4 days ago
  • Jurassic Strike Force 5 #1 by BW Media – 4 days ago
  • Misadventures of Adam West #4 by BW Media – 5 days ago
  • Doctor Who #14 by BW Media – 6 days ago
  • Justice League International (2011-) #6 by BW Media – 1 week ago
  • Transformers Robots In Disguise Ongoing #1 by BW Media – 1 week ago
  • Young Justice (2011-) #13 by BW Media – 1 week ago

Latest Reviews

  • Mega Man #10 by BW Media – 14 hours ago
  • Voltron #2 by BW Media – 2 days ago
  • American Vampire #23 by dccomicsfan – 3 days ago
  • Whispers #1 by dccomicsfan – 3 days ago
  • The Activity #2 by dccomicsfan – 3 days ago
  • Activity #1 by dccomicsfan – 3 days ago
  • The Unwritten #33.5 by dccomicsfan – 3 days ago
  • Usagi Yojimbo #143 by dccomicsfan – 3 days ago
  • Sonic the Hedgehog #233 by BW Media – 3 days ago
  • Voodoo (2011-) #5 by plgirdler – 3 days ago

Recent Comments

  • Severed #7 (of 7) (MR) (4) – 2 days ago
  • Typologies (1) – 2 days ago
  • Whispers #1 (3) – 3 days ago
  • Wolverine and the X-Men #5 Xregg (1) – 3 days ago
  • Severed #7 (of 7) (MR) (4) – 3 days ago
  • Deadpool Vol. 3 #50 (1) – 4 days ago
  • Mister Terrific (2011-) #6 (1) – 4 days ago
  • Action Comics (2011-) #6 (5) – 4 days ago
  • Green Arrow (2011-) #1 (11) – 4 days ago
  • Green Lantern (2011-) #6 (1) – 5 days ago
 
About Us  |  FAQ  |  Copyright Notices  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use  |  Ad Specs  |  iPhone  |  Podcast  |  Retailers  |  Contact Us